Home › Academy › Down payment invoice vs proforma invoice
Down Payment Invoice vs Proforma Invoice
A customer asks for a deposit before you start. You have two documents that look almost identical — a down payment invoice and a proforma invoice — and sending the wrong one is the most expensive paperwork mistake a small seller makes. One takes money and binds both sides. The other takes no money and binds nobody. This page is the seller-side comparison: when to send each, what each must contain, and the tax trap that catches sellers who collect a deposit against a proforma.
Every search result for this comparison describes the two documents. None of them answers the question a seller actually has at the keyboard: which one do I send right now, for this deposit? That is the question this page answers. The sources below are named throughout — the comparison sites that own the query today (invoicesoftwarefinder, djaboo), and the UK VAT guidance the tax section rests on (HMRC Notice 700, via tradetally, berbertax, saidtopaid, and Xero).
The short answer (one takes money, one doesn’t)
A down payment invoice is a real invoice for part of the total, issued after the order is agreed. The buyer pays it, the money is yours to hold against the job, and it goes on your books as a receivable and then as revenue when the work is done. A proforma invoice is a preliminary document that previews the deal — the same shape as an invoice, but not a payment demand and not an accounting record. The buyer uses it to approve the spend, arrange financing, or value goods for customs.
The rule of thumb: if money is about to change hands, send a down payment invoice. If nobody is paying yet and the buyer just needs the numbers in writing, send a proforma. That one sentence resolves most of the confusion — the rest of this page is the cases where it does not, and the tax trap in the middle.
What a down payment invoice is (and when to send one)
A down payment invoice — also called a deposit invoice or advance payment invoice — is issued by a seller to request upfront payment, or a partial amount, before delivering goods or services. That is the definition invoicesoftwarefinder uses, and it matches how the document works in practice: it secures the payment and the buyer’s commitment, and it initiates the payment process. Unlike a proforma, it is issued after the agreement to proceed, not during the negotiation.
It is a real invoice, with the same legal obligations as a standard invoice. Djaboo puts it plainly: a deposit invoice “formalizes this partial payment, with the same legal obligations as a standard invoice,” and must include the same legal information — identification of the parties, invoice reference, date, deposit amount, and the applicable VAT rate. It goes on your books, in your real invoice sequence, and it creates a receivable the moment you issue it.
Send one when:
- The work is custom or the order is large. A deposit commits the buyer before you spend a day on something you cannot resell.
- You have to buy materials up front. The deposit funds the purchase instead of your overdraft.
- The customer is new. A deposit is the cheapest credit check there is.
- The lead time is long. A paid deposit holds the slot and the price.
What it must contain: both parties, an invoice number from your real sequence, the date, the deposit amount, the VAT or tax rate and amount, the order or contract reference, what the deposit covers, and the remaining balance with when it falls due. And the cancellation terms — what happens to the deposit if either side walks away — belong in writing before the money moves, not in an argument after it.
The deposit is deducted on the final invoice. Worked example — the numbers are illustrative, not a price list:
| Description | Amount |
|---|---|
| Custom shelving, agreed total | $3,000.00 |
| Deposit paid on down payment invoice INV-042 | −$900.00 |
| Balance due on final invoice | $2,100.00 |
Check the arithmetic: $3,000 − $900 = $2,100 due. The final invoice shows the full total, less the deposit already paid, so the buyer can see the whole job and the credit in one place — and your books never count the same $900 twice.
What a proforma invoice is (and when to send one)
A proforma invoice is a preliminary document provided by a seller to a buyer, serving as an estimate or quotation for a potential transaction. It outlines the terms, conditions, costs, and specifications of the proposed purchase. It is not legally binding — invoicesoftwarefinder, Payoneer, and Xero all say so in the same words — and it is not a payment demand. Xero’s guide puts the accounting consequence plainly: because no payment is due, a proforma “stays off your books until a final invoice is raised” and is not recorded in accounts receivable.
Send one when:
- The buyer needs internal approval. A formal-looking document moves faster through a finance department than an email quote.
- The buyer needs financing or a letter of credit. The bank wants the numbers on a document before it releases funds.
- Goods cross a border. Customs may want a declared value before the shipment moves — though the commercial invoice, not the proforma, is what clears the goods.
- Both sides want the terms in writing before signing. The proforma says “here’s what we’d agree to” while changes are still cheap.
Mark it clearly: “PROFORMA INVOICE — NOT A TAX INVOICE” at the top. HMRC’s guidance says pro formas should be clearly described as such, preferably carrying the words “This is not a VAT invoice.” Give proformas their own numbering sequence (PI-001, PI-002) so they never consume a number from your real invoice sequence — an auditor should be able to see at a glance that proformas never represented actual revenue.
One honest complication: a proforma can invite a deposit. HMRC describes proformas as documents against which payment is invited, often where the supplier will not supply until payment arrives, and Payoneer notes they are often used to secure payment before delivery. That is common practice — and it is exactly where the tax trap below bites. The cleaner route, when money is actually being requested, is the down payment invoice. Our sibling page takes the cautious line — that a buyer shouldn’t pay against a proforma and you shouldn’t ask them to — and for most sellers that caution is the right default. The next section explains why.
The comparison table (binding, payment, timing, accounting)
| Down payment invoice | Proforma invoice | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Secure part-payment and the buyer’s commitment | Preview terms; approval, financing, customs valuation |
| Legally binding | Yes — a real invoice, a formal payment request under the agreed order or contract | No — a preliminary, non-binding estimate |
| Payment | Due on issue, for the stated part of the total | No payment due |
| Timing | After the agreement to proceed, before delivery | During negotiation, before the deal closes |
| Accounting | Recorded as a receivable; deposit deducted on the final invoice | Not recorded; stays off the books until a final invoice is raised |
| Tax / VAT | VAT due when the deposit is received (UK) | No tax point on its own — but payment against it creates one |
| Numbering | Your real invoice sequence | Its own PI sequence, never the real one |
| If the buyer walks away | The deposit is generally kept under the contract terms — rules vary by country | Nothing to refund — no money changed hands |
The simplest test, from the comparison itself: if the buyer is about to pay, it is a down payment invoice. If paying would be premature or impossible, it is a proforma.
The VAT trap (payment against a proforma creates a tax point)
This section is about VAT — the UK and EU tax. If you sell only in the US, there is no VAT tax point; state sales-tax rules on deposits vary by state, so check yours. For VAT-registered sellers, the trap is real and it is the live confusion in the current guides.
The rule, from HMRC’s VAT manual as reported by tradetally: a pro forma invoice “does not function as a VAT invoice and does not, by itself, create a tax point.” A tax point — the date that determines when VAT becomes due — is triggered by delivery of goods, completion of a service, or receipt of payment, whichever happens first. A pro forma sitting in someone’s inbox does none of those things, so on its own it creates no VAT obligation.
The trap is the payment. The instant a customer pays against a pro forma, even as a deposit, that payment date becomes the tax point. From there you are on the clock: you must issue a proper VAT invoice within 30 days, and you owe the VAT on that amount in the VAT period the payment falls in — not the period when the job finishes. Berbertax states the underlying rule the same way: deposits are normally taxed when received, and GOV.UK says VAT on an advance payment is due when it is received or when a VAT invoice is issued for it, whichever happens first. (Returnable deposits are the exception — a refundable security deposit on hired goods, for example, is not taxed on receipt.)
Two mistakes follow from the same misunderstanding. First, treating the deposit as “not yet a sale” and reporting it a quarter late — the VAT was due in the period the money arrived. Second, letting the buyer reclaim VAT from the proforma: a pro forma cannot be used as evidence to reclaim input tax, even if it shows every detail a VAT invoice would show (HMRC Notice 700, paragraph 17.3). A buyer who files the proforma as a purchase invoice has no valid evidence for the VAT it claims, and a seller who posts a proforma into the ledger as if it were a sale has misstated revenue.
The fix is boring, which is why it works: if you asked for money, issue the down payment invoice — a proper VAT invoice — instead of the proforma. The tax point is the same date either way, but the paperwork is correct from the start, the buyer can reclaim the VAT, and there is no 30-day clock running on a document that was never meant to be an invoice. And label every proforma “This is not a VAT invoice,” so nobody downstream mistakes it for one.
Which one to send for a deposit
Decide by what happens next, not by what the document is called:
- Money is needed before you start — materials, a held slot, a new customer. Send a down payment invoice.
- The buyer only needs the numbers approved — internal sign-off, a budget line, a purchase order. Send a proforma.
- The buyer needs to pay before you order materials. Send a down payment invoice — that is the document the payment belongs on.
- Goods are crossing a border and customs wants a value first. Send a proforma for the valuation, then the commercial invoice to clear the goods. See proforma invoice vs commercial invoice for that pair.
- The buyer needs financing or a letter of credit. Send a proforma for the bank, then a down payment invoice when the money is actually requested.
The clean sequence for a job with a deposit is three documents, in order: proforma to agree the terms, down payment invoice to take the deposit, final invoice for the full total less the deposit already paid. Never send two documents for the same money — a proforma and a down payment invoice covering the same deposit is how duplicate payments and double-counted revenue happen. When the down payment invoice goes out, retire the proforma explicitly: “proforma PI-014 is now superseded by deposit invoice INV-042.”
How to make either free with Billia
The down payment invoice is a standard invoice for part of the total: build it with the free invoice generator — line items, the deposit amount, the VAT line, and the balance still due printed on the page, then the final invoice deducts the deposit with the same tool. The proforma is built with the free proforma invoice generator, which pre-fills “This is a proforma invoice — not a tax invoice” in the notes, so the labeling HMRC asks for is already on the document. Both are free — no signup, no watermark — and both produce a clean PDF you can send as-is. For the numbers behind either document, see how to write an invoice and the proforma invoice definition.
A down payment invoice takes money and binds both sides; a proforma takes no money and binds nobody. Send the one that matches what happens next — and if money is moving, make it the down payment invoice, so the tax paperwork is right from the day the deposit lands.
Make either document — free
A down payment invoice for the deposit, or a proforma to agree the terms first. Billia’s free generators — no signup, no watermark.
Create a down payment invoice — free Create a proforma invoice — freeFrequently asked questions
Is a down payment invoice legally binding?
Yes, in the practical sense: it is a real invoice, not a quote — a formal request for payment that creates a receivable on your books, issued under an order or contract both sides have agreed. The binding force comes from that order or contract plus the payment. In France, for example, a paid down payment binds both sides under Article 1590 of the Civil Code (djaboo). Rules vary by country, so put the cancellation terms in writing before the money moves.
Can I ask for a deposit on a proforma invoice?
Yes — HMRC describes proformas as documents against which payment is invited, often where the supplier will not supply until payment arrives. But the moment the money lands, the payment date becomes the VAT tax point and a proper VAT invoice is due within 30 days, so the cleaner route is a down payment invoice. A proforma is the right document for agreeing terms; a down payment invoice is the right document for taking money.
Does a proforma invoice count for tax?
No, on its own: it is not a VAT invoice, it creates no tax point, it cannot be used to reclaim VAT, and it is not recorded in your accounts. But payment against it does create a tax point — the instant a customer pays against a proforma, even as a deposit, the payment date becomes the tax point and a proper VAT invoice must follow within 30 days. That is the trap: the document is tax-neutral, the payment is not.
What should a down payment invoice include?
The same legal information as a standard invoice: both parties, an invoice number from your real sequence, the date, the deposit amount, the applicable VAT or tax rate and amount, the order or contract reference, what the deposit covers, and the remaining balance with when it falls due. Add the cancellation terms — what happens to the deposit if either side walks away — before the money moves.